Conquest of Southern Tang by Song

In 975 AD the Song managed through force to subdue the state now known as Southern Tang, to distinguish it from the synonymously named Tang Dynasty, as part of a series of Song conquests to reunify China.

Battle on the Yangtze
On the river Yangtze near Nanking, the then capital of the Southern Tang, a major naval battle took place in 975 between the Song empire and the Southern Tang.

Southern Tang
The Tang had a fleet of ships that were ten decks high and equipped with multiple flamethrowers. There were at least 150,000 soldiers and sailors under the command of Chu Ling Pin.

Song empire
The admiral for the Song was Tshao Pin, The Song ships were smaller however the crew on board were better archers. The ships had flamethrowers and were filled with bundles of reed soaked in oil to be thrown at the enemy ships.

Battle
The Song ships attacked ferociously, firing so many arrows that soon, the Tang ships were studded with them. Chu Ling Pin then ordered the flamethrowers to be fired. Normally, any attacker would be destroyed, however the wind blew in the opposite direction of the flamethrowers so the burning oil flew back onto the Tang. At that moment, the Song started throwing the bundles of burning reeds into the wind to cause more damage. The Song may have started using their own flamethrowers at this stage. About 150,000 Tang soldiers and sailors were killed in the fire and Chu Ling Pin committed suicide by jumping into the flames.

Analysis of Battle
Considering the position of Nanking in China, where the imperial capital would have been, and the above "evidence". It can be assumed that there was a strong westerly wind on the day of that battle. The attackers would have had the advantage of having a good wind behind them, their ships would have travelled much faster, and their arrows, "burning bundles" and burning oil would have had extra propulsion. However, the defending side would have had the exact opposite to this. Considering the claimed size of the defenders ships, Chu Ling Pin would have probably been inside the ship and may have not been aware of what the weather was like, which would have led him to make the mistake of ordering the flamethrowers to be fired. On a technological note, we know that the Wujing Zongyao written in 1044 (although the oldest edition is from around the 1560s) describes the flamethrowers oil being lit by fire drug (a flammable, quasi explosive compound that would in later cultures and generations be refined into gunpowder) and we know that fire drug was invented as a medicine sometime in the 9th century, but whether this battle did use gunpowder is speculative.

Aftermath
Li Houzhu the emperor of the Southern Tang was more interested in poetry than ruling and soon after this battle the Southern Tang were absorbed into the new Song Empire. He was captured and sent to the Song capital, one of his wives raped and he was eventually poisoned.

Source

 * Joseph Needham's Science and Civilisation in China Volume 5 Part 7 the Gunpowder Epic, page 89

宋灭南唐之战