This article refers to discrimination against soldiers of the armed forces of the United Kingdom which encompasses the Royal Navy, the British Army and the Royal Air Force.[1]
In December 2007, the Prime Minister requested a report to evaluate the relationship between “our Armed Forces and the rest of society”.[2] The report to the Prime Minister refers to a number of incidents, namely: An army officer was refused entry to Harrods in November 2006 (Harrods continues to refuse entrance to persons in ‘combat dress’); Troops returning from Afghanistan were told to change into civilian clothes at Birmingham Airport in December 2007; Troops returning from Afghanistan into Edinburgh Airport were directed away from the public areas through ad hoc facilities in 2007; Patients from the Armed Forces rehabilitation centre at Headley Court were subjected to verbal abuse in November 2007;[3] RAF personnel were banned from wearing uniform in Peterborough after incidents of verbal abuse; and there were other unreported incidents of discrimination and harassment against soldiers.[4] In December 2008, a pizza shop discontinued offering discounts to members of the British troops but continued to offer such discounts to the police, the fire service and NHS staff.[5] On 4 September 2008, the Metro Hotel refused a wounded soldier a room, forcing him to spend the night in his car.[6] Moreover, there were incidents of public houses banning soldiers in 2002.[7]
Current legal practice[]
As for the Metro Hotel, legal experts confirmed it was not against the law for hotel staff to turn away a potential customer because of his or her job.[8] The report to the Prime Minister states that “It is quite intolerable that those who wear the Queen’s uniform should be denied access to public or commercial services as a result, but there is no legal protection for the targets of such discrimination.” [9]
Proposals to improve the situation are limited to the “legal protection of the uniform”.[10] Thus, a hotel could, presumably, still refuse an officer who did not wear his uniform. For example, the Metro Hotel refused the non-uniformed soldier when he presented his army warrant card.[11] Some members of the public have taken matters into their own hands. Metro Hotel had to call the police as their lines were flooded with angry, abusive and threatening calls.[12] Mr Kai Graf von der Pahlen and Mr Taha Idris of the Swansea Bay Racial Equality Council published research on ‘soldier discrimination’ [13] which raises the question whether ‘soldier discrimination’ may amount to unlawful, indirect gender discrimination. The research shows that male soldiers may have a case for unlawful gender discrimination because most of the soldiers of the UK Armed Forces are male. The discriminator is thus effectively excluding a pre-dominantly (approximately 90%) male group of people which is classed as “indirect gender discrimination” under the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 and, therefore, unlawful.[14]
References[]
- ↑ Ministry of Defence [internet] http://www.mod.uk/DefenceInternet/Home
- ↑ Davies, Q., Clark, B., and Sharp, M. 2008. Report of Inquiry into National Recognition of our Armed Forces, Report to the Prime Minister. May, p.3
- ↑ Davies, Q., Clark, B., and Sharp, M. 2008. Report of Inquiry into National Recognition of our Armed Forces, Report to the Prime Minister. May, p.39
- ↑ Davies, Q., Clark, B., and Sharp, M. 2008. Report of Inquiry into National Recognition of our Armed Forces, Report to the Prime Minister. May, p.40
- ↑ Daily Mail Reporter, 2008. Soldier's fury as pizza shop ends discounts for troops... but keeps them for police, fire and NHS staff. MailOnline, [internet], 31 December.
- ↑ Fletcher, H., 2008. Soldier forced to sleep in car after hotel refuses him a room. Timesonline, [internet], 5 September. Available at http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article4674411.ece
- ↑ Anonymous, 2002. Soldiers banned from pubs in Stamford. BBC, [internet] 6 July. Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/lincolnshire/news/2002/07/06/army_drinkers.shtml
- ↑ Staples, J., 2008. Soldier is turfed out of hotel for being in Army. Metro, 5 September, p.5
- ↑ Davies, Q., Clark, B., and Sharp, M. 2008. Report of Inquiry into National Recognition of our Armed Forces, Report to the Prime Minister. May, p.17
- ↑ Davies, Q., Clark, B., and Sharp, M. 2008. Report of Inquiry into National Recognition of our Armed Forces, Report to the Prime Minister. May, p.6
- ↑ Fletcher, H., 2008. Soldier forced to sleep in car after hotel refuses him a room. Timesonline, [internet], 5 September. Available at http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article4674411.ece
- ↑ Fletcher, H., 2008. Soldier forced to sleep in car after hotel refuses him a room. Timesonline, [internet], 5 September. Available at http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article4674411.ece
- ↑ Graf Pahlen, K. and Idris, T., “Joining Forces”, Solicitors Journal, Vol. 153 no 43 17-11-2009, http://www.solicitorsjournal.com
- ↑ Graf Pahlen, K. and Idris, T., “Joining Forces”, Solicitors Journal, Vol. 153 no 43 17-11-2009, http://www.solicitorsjournal.com
The original article can be found at Soldier discrimination in the United Kingdom and the edit history here.